lils ([info]gleemie) wrote,
@ 2008-07-26 01:40:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
I did it. I saw X-Files.
It was a way more whacked out experience than I expected.

One blogger writes about how the burdens of consistency stifled X-Files' creative freedom in its later seasons. While I lost interest after my first three seasons of obsession, consistency really killed the first hour of the X-Files for me. For some reason, the first half of the movie felt like a scrapbook of vignettes meant to demonstrate and remind of who the characters were -- Mulder, wry and sad, and Scully, scientific and assertive. Check, check. But they felt like symbols. There wasn't really humor or a connection.

A theme in the movie was stubborness. Mulder stubbornly refused to give up. Scully stubbornly and inexplicably refused to stop being an asshole to the psychic pedophile self-hating priest. One of the FBI agents throughout the movie just disbelieved Mulder and the psychic without any well developed reason. All this stubborness! And it fell on its face because the characters felt flat. Instead of making us feel somehow the relationships among the characters by developing them, the movie tries to coast on the audience's memories from 10 years ago.

And the most whack thing was that Scully and Mulder are clearly friends in the movie. Until an hour in when out of nowhere, they're in bed together like an old married couple, talking about their worries and sharing an awkward kiss in which Scully pushes Mulder's face away, saying "scratchy beard." I wanted to die of awkwardness. Here, they'd just gotten together and they were already divorced. And on top of that, the amazing thing about Mulder and Scully's romantic tension on the show was that you would get really involved in the characters and it would build really slowly over time. The movie's relationship reveal was like saying "Um, I like you." "Oh, I guess I like you to." "Okay, I guess we should kiss." Maybe I missed something in the later seasons where they got together? I remember hearing secondhand of something about a Scully miscarriage rumored to Mulder's kid, but I thought it was an unresolved mystery and an opportunity for fan fic speculation.

Those were the main drawbacks of the movie. That said, I definitely am glad I saw it because it was at least emotionally intense for me. :) Quite an experience. The mystery was pretty interesting and they tied together many seemingly disparate plot lines and themes by the end. While there were a few guessable turns, it kept me involved and thinking about the mystery.

And, as Camellia and I had hoped and joked, there were a few cute shots of david duchovny.




(Post a new comment)


[info]lucylou
2008-07-26 01:44 pm UTC (link)
I know what you mean, completely, about the movie being stifled by its consistency. My biggest beef had to do with the "conflict" between Mulder and Scully. Throughout the series and previous movie, Scully feels like she's holding Mulder back, while he insists that she's all that keeps him sane. Over and over again, we see this dynamic play out, Scully pulling back and Mulder pleading with her to stay. In the new movie, though, she's like, "I, for some reason, don't like that you're involved with the FBI anymore, even though I was the one to push you back into it." to which he's like, "Whatevs, lady. Bye."
Out of character! It was like the writers said, "We need a conflict between M & S. Go."

That said, having obsessively watched every season, I know about how they got together romantically, and I was actually really impressed with both that transition, and how they handled it in the movie. These are people who had to maintain this friendship and professional relationship for many years. Their romantic relationship developed from that, and Chris Carter always kept it subtle. It was refreshing not to see a show carry on about the characters getting together. It actually happened very smoothly, without any big stupid love scenes, and you got the impression that they wanted their relationship to remain the mostly the same, while enjoying their private time together, too. I admit that seeing them in bed together might have been jarring if you stopped watching after a few seasons, but I was going, "Oh man, Scully totally lives there too!" from the beginning. I've often wondered how they'd live after the series, and the preview for the movie indicated that they'd split up. I liked this much better-- I don't think those characters could function separately, and I'm glad they handled it they way they did. They were together almost 24/7 for, what, 9 years in the series and 7 outside of the series. They've got the stats to aquire that old-married-couple feel. I just like seeing a couple that isn't obvious about it, you know?

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]lucylou
2008-07-26 01:50 pm UTC (link)
Oh yeah! Also: In the post-credit scene, after about a million hours of panning over ice and crap, it begins to pan over water, and then sloooowly we see a boat in the distance. It's like a tiny rowboat. Then we see that there's a dude rowing it backwards over the Mediterranean waters, and as the camera pans over from above, from about a thousand feet, we see that it's Mulder in a swimsuit, and Scully is reclining in a bikini in the bow. Then they both wave up a the (presumably) black helicopter hovering overhead and filming them.

A little cheesy maybe, but I giggled. It's nice to see such long-suffering characters get their happy-time.
And, you know, it was hot.

But I wondered: Did that mean that the kid that Scully had operated on had died? And they'd gone away to "escape the darkness?"

Shrug. M & S in bathing suits.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]lianthe
2008-07-28 05:51 am UTC (link)
Scully's had a couple of kids, supposedly. There was Emily, who was biologically Scully's kid (though she thought at first it was her sister's kid) but this was a child concieved of Scully's eggs which were stolen while she was abducted, and Scully never knew about it.

Scully did actually give birth to a baby. He was William, whom they mention in the movie. They never make it clear whether or not it actually IS Mulder's child; they don't do DNA tests or anything, but to Scully and Mulder that is inconsequential and they both consider the baby to be Mulder's child.

Scully gives him him for adoption in season 9, hence his absence.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]gleemie
2008-07-28 05:53 am UTC (link)
ooh, thanks for catching me up. :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…